3.jpg
FOT scores in Forestry Plan Issue Resolution
Friday, 13 February 2009 19:35

FOT scores in Forestry Plan Issue Resolution

The Friends of Temagami has won some concessions in the 2009-2019 Temagami Forest Management Plan. In response to FOT’s Issue Resolution request, filed in June 2008, Ministry of Natural Resources Regional Director Eric Doidge has made changes to the final plan. These include:

· Long-term road density in Special Management Areas will be capped at 0.55 km/km2. This recognizes the density as a maximum, not an average.

· Decommissioning will be considered as a road use strategy. This is the first time that a specific strategy for road abandonment has been identified.

· Secondary canoe routes will not be created. This may have led to a lower level of protection for existing canoe routes.

· Youth camps and canoeists will be involved in cultural heritage planning. We had previously been barred from sitting on the Cultural Heritage Task Team.

· Viewpoint access trails will receive a T1 Area of Concern. This 30 m reserve and 30 m modified reserve is the highest level of protection afforded hiking trails.

· Six viewpoints will receive permanent recognition: Florence Lake Ridge, Dry Lake Ridge, Chee-skon Ridge, Pinetorch Fire Tower, Blueberry Lake Ridge, and Dalton Lake Ridge.

· Native people will be consulted regarding logging in the Spirit Forest.

FOT will now ensure that all portages, as well as youth camp and canoeing heritage values, are recognized and protected. We will also participate in the review of the Temagami Land Use Plan, expected in 2009.

 

What worked well

FOT has been involved at every step of this FMP, starting in July 2007. Three FOT members sit on the Temagami Local Citizens’ Committee, which provides advice to the MNR on forest management issues. Those three members each spent time as the LCC’s rotational member on the MNR’s Forest Management Planning Team. FOT has participated in every opportunity for value identification and public input, spearheading two successful letter writing campaigns.

FOT also helped the Town of Latchford protect the Burns and Coleman Trails and Greenwood Provincial Park. Unbeknownst to Latchford, the MNR prepared plans to log the trails adjacent to Greenwood Park, both key parts of the town’s tourism strategy. FOT notified Latchford of the plans then provided assistance as they launched their own successful issue resolution. These historic trails are now protected.

Early in the forest management planning process, FOT collaborated with other environmental groups and tourist businesses to identify problem areas and ways of tackling them. This cooperation ensured that when those groups went to issue resolution, no group carried too heavy a load and no issue was overlooked. FOT has maintained contact with these groups as they pursued their own issue resolutions. Issues they brought forth include logging old-growth red and white pine, logging in Temagami’s western backcountry, logging over cross-country ski trails, protection for the Ottawa-Temiskaming Highland Trail, and increased harvest level projections. FOT continues to support these groups in their ongoing efforts.

In June 2008, after failing to make significant headway, FOT launched an Issue Resolution complaint regarding the draft forestry plan. After two unsuccessful rounds of meetings with local MNR staff, we felt that a change in tactic was required to make headway and gain on our issues. We modified the FOT’s initial request by “agreeing to disagree” on some important issues: clearcuts larger than 260 hectares, rapid implementation of the Federal Species at Risk Act, and the development of short and medium term road density targets. We dropped our request to have four minor viewpoints recognized, but kept our request for two major viewpoints. In exchange for doing this, we requested a cap on long-term road density, recognition of road decommissioning, greater involvement in cultural heritage management, and protection for viewpoint access trails. Most importantly, we reiterated our strong opposition to secondary canoe routes and portages.

This strategy paid off allowing FOT to win the highest level of protection we could reasonably expect through this process. With upcoming forest management planning processes in the Sudbury and Timiskaming Districts, the lessons learned will soon be put to use. However, this does not mean that all is well in Temagami. More roads will be built in the short term, endangered species are still at elevated risk, large clearcuts are more frequent and Spirit Forest may be among them. The new protections we earned pale in comparison to what still needs to be done. With your help, Friends of Temagami will continue to fight for Temagami’s wild spaces.